When does a new fund need to be on the policy?
Before it starts investing. Most firms also want it there before the fund takes investor money or a partner joins a portfolio company’s board, whichever comes first. If your investors have asked for insurance in diligence, their deadline sets yours. Tell your broker when you start raising, so there are a few weeks to read the wording and compare options. Whether the fund qualifies turns on the policy’s definitions and endorsements, the amendments to its terms, and a fund need not always be named individually. Confirm it in the wording before the fund invests.
Why a new fund may fall outside the policy
An investment firm is usually several legal entities: a management company, one or more general partners (the entities that run each fund), the funds, and sometimes special purpose vehicles (entities set up for a single deal). A policy covers only the entities and people that qualify as insureds under its definitions and endorsements, so insuring the management company doesn’t automatically cover every fund.
Policies describe their insureds in different ways, and the forms vary by insurer. Some include a new fund on their own terms, often with conditions attached; others need it added by endorsement. A fund need not always be named individually to qualify, so the only way to know is to read the definitions and endorsements against your entity chart. The same check matters for firms that have had the same policies for years: newer vehicles don’t always make it on.
When to add it
Get the new fund onto the policy before it starts investing. It should also be there before the fund takes investor money or a partner joins a portfolio company’s board, whichever comes first. If investors have asked for insurance as part of their diligence, their deadline sets yours. Where the fund has to be added, that is the insurer’s decision rather than a formality, so starting a few weeks ahead leaves time to read the wording, ask how the fund is added, and compare options if the policies need to change.
Investors’ requirements tell you what they want to see. They don’t tell you whether the policy names the new fund, or whether D&O (cover for decisions about running the firm and its funds) and E&O (cover for the investment work itself) share one limit. Read the requirement as a floor, not as proof that the policy fits.
If you are choosing a broker at the same time, one question sorts the useful ones from the rest: which of our funds, general partners, management company and vehicles would be named on the policy, and how do you add a fund we raise next year?
What changes once the fund is added
Several entities often share one limit, the most the policy pays. If the new fund shares a limit with the manager and the older funds, one large claim can use up what is available for everything else, and legal fees usually come out of the same limit that pays settlements. The Bruckmann, Rosser, Sherrill case below shows legal fees coming out of the limit and two policies that could not be added together. Before the fund is added, ask whether it shares a limit and whether that still fits.
A new fund can also bring new questions with it. A later fund that follows on into an earlier fund’s company, or that wants a deal the older fund’s investors expected to see, raises conflict questions between funds at the same firm. Our guide on conflicts of interest between funds at the same firm covers how a policy treats a claim brought by a fund’s own investors, and why the usual safeguard is a written allocation policy that is followed.
How Cilantro helps
Send us your entity chart, including the fund you are forming, your current policies with all endorsements, and any insurance requirement from your investors. We map your entities, and the people who act for each, against the policy, tell you in plain English which funds the wording includes and which it does not, and ask the insurer to add the new fund before it starts investing.
If the policies need to change, we go to insurers for terms that fit and set the quotes side by side, including the fine print, so you can decide with a broker’s advice. If the new fund is your first, the same materials are enough for us to tell you what to put in place before it takes investor money.
What happens when the coverage doesn’t fit
Having insurance doesn’t settle what it covers. The public court record below involves other firms, not Cilantro clients, and each outcome depended on its own facts, policy language, and governing law.
Bruckmann, Rosser, Sherrill & Co. v. Marsh USA
A private equity firm settled a lawsuit and then sought more insurance money than it had received. The dispute was about whether the limits of two policies could be combined.
The 2011 New York opinion records a $33.5 million settlement, $6.9 million in legal fees that came out of the policy limits, and $20 million paid by insurers in total. The court enforced clauses that prevented the two limits from being added together. It did not make a final finding that the broker was negligent.
What we check for you: Whether your policies can be combined, and how much of each limit legal fees can use up, before you count on the total.
New York Appellate Division opinion, June 28, 2011