Who pays when a partner is sued over a portfolio company board seat?
Usually the portfolio company’s own D&O policy, as long as the claim is about the partner’s work as its director. If the claim is about what the partner did for your fund, that policy may not cover it, and the question moves to your firm’s policy, which answers only if it covers outside board seats. One claim can involve both, and then the wording of each policy decides which pays first and who picks the lawyer. Send us your policy and the seat, and we set out the order.
Two policies, one board seat
A partner on a portfolio company’s board is covered by two policies that answer different questions. The portfolio company’s D&O policy covers your partner in their role as that company’s director. Your firm’s policy may cover the management company, the general partners, the funds and the people who act for each, but only those it names.
A claim can draw both policies in at once. Which one pays first, and whether either reaches the firm itself, depends on what each policy says about outside board seats. Being covered as a director under the portfolio company’s policy does not mean your fund is covered.
Where the gap opens
People at investment firms often hold several roles: partner at the fund, director of a portfolio company, manager of another vehicle. A D&O policy covers a person only in the roles it describes. A claim about what someone did in a different role may fall outside it.
That is how a partner can be insured under two policies and still find a claim excluded from both. The portfolio company’s policy may exclude what the partner did for the fund, and the firm’s policy may not name outside board seats at all. The Goggin case below is an example: an exclusion for what directors did in a separate role outside the company applied to directors who were insured.
What to check before a partner takes the seat
The time to check is before the partner joins the board, not after a claim arrives. For each seat, we read your policy and, when you can get it, the portfolio company’s, and set out:
- Whether your firm’s policy covers outside board seats, and whether this one is included
- Whether the portfolio company’s policy excludes what your partner does on the fund’s behalf
- Which policy responds first, and who picks the lawyer
- Whether D&O and E&O (cover for the firm’s investment work) on your policy share one limit (the most the policy pays), so a long defense of one claim leaves less for the next
- What happens to the partner’s cover when the portfolio company is sold
How Cilantro helps
We list every role your people hold, including board seats and other vehicles, and check each one against the policy. We can also look at a portfolio company’s D&O before your partner joins its board, so you know who pays first and where the gaps are.
Send us your entity chart, your current policies and the board seats your partners hold. We tell you in plain English what you have and what is missing, and then go to insurers for terms that fit.
What happens when the coverage doesn’t fit
Having insurance doesn’t settle what it covers. The public court record below involves other firms, not Cilantro clients, and each outcome depended on its own facts, policy language, and governing law.
Goggin v. National Union Fire Insurance
Two directors of U.S. Coal also managed separate investment entities. When claims were made about what they did in those overlapping roles, they asked for coverage under a D&O policy.
In November 2018, the Delaware Superior Court ruled that an exclusion for acts in an outside capacity applied to the claims tied to the investment entities. The ruling was about that one policy. It was not a finding of misconduct, and it did not say the directors had no insurance anywhere.
What we check for you: Every role your people hold, including board seats and other vehicles, and which policy covers each one.
Delaware Superior Court opinion, November 30, 2018