Does insuring the management company cover the funds and the general partner too?
Not automatically. A policy covers only the entities and people it defines as insured. The manager, the general partner, each fund and each individual are separate to an insurer, and each has to fall within that definition. The policy also decides whether the funds share one limit, the most the policy pays, with the manager. List every entity and person, check each against the wording, and ask to have anything missing added.
What D&O and E&O each cover for a hedge fund manager
D&O is about people and the decisions they make. If a partner or officer is sued over how they managed the firm or a fund, D&O is the coverage built for that claim, subject to the policy’s terms. The first test is whether the person was acting in a role the policy covers. The policy’s exclusions and reporting rules still apply. E&O is about the work the firm does for investors. Someone may claim the firm made a mistake in managing their money: investing outside the stated guidelines, a valuation an investor disputes, or a conflict that was not disclosed. E&O is the coverage built for those claims. The first test is whether the policy describes that service, and its exclusions still apply.
A fund losing money is not, on its own, a claim. Ordinary market losses are not covered, and liability insurance does not guarantee performance. Disputes tend to be about the gap between what the documents said and what the firm did. How a policy responds depends on the facts and its terms, so these are examples and not promises of coverage.
Who has to be on the policy
Like other investment firms, a hedge fund manager is usually several legal entities: the management company or adviser, the general partner, each fund and any other entity set up to hold investments, and the people who act for them. Insuring the management company does not automatically cover every fund or every partner, because each has to be inside the policy’s definition of who is insured. Launching a new fund or adding a new strategy or service is a reason to check the policy again, because an existing policy does not always pick them up.
People at investment firms often hold several roles, and a D&O policy covers a person only in the roles it describes. In the Goggin case below, two directors were insured under a D&O policy, and the court still found that claims tied to their work for separate investment entities were excluded. List every role your people hold, including any seat on an outside board, whether at a company the fund invests in or another organization, and check each one against the policy.
One policy or two, and what to check
D&O and E&O for investment managers are often sold together as general partners liability (GPL). GPL is the name of the combined policy, not a third kind of coverage. The policy’s name does not tell you which entities, claims or services are included. Many combined policies have one shared limit, so a large claim under one part leaves less for the other. Legal fees usually come out of the same limit that pays settlements, and there is usually a retention, the amount you pay before the policy does, like a deductible.
Most of these policies are claims-made, which means they cover claims made and reported while the policy is active, often only for work done after a set date, called the retroactive date. A problem you already know about that could lead to a claim generally has to be reported to your current insurer before you change insurers. Fines, penalties, deliberate misconduct, problems you knew about before the policy started and promises made in contracts are commonly excluded. A regulator’s exam, an informal request, a subpoena and a formal proceeding are different stages, and a policy may cover some and not others.
Some policies will also pay to correct an operational error, such as a trade placed in the wrong account or for the wrong quantity, before anyone makes a claim. This is called cost of corrections. It usually has to be added to the policy, it usually has its own limit and retention, and you generally need the insurer’s consent before you spend anything.
How Cilantro helps
Send us an entity chart: the adviser or management company, the general partner, the funds and any other investment entities. Add a description of your services and strategy, your current policies with endorsements (the amendments to their terms), and any requirement from investors or a contract. We list every entity, person and role and check each against the policy. We tell you whether D&O and E&O share one limit and whether legal fees reduce it. When we go to market, we ask insurers for cost of corrections.
When two proposals have similar prices and limits, the difference is in the fine print. We read the full policy forms, not just the summaries, and put the differences in writing so you can decide. Investor diligence questions are a good place to start: send us what your investors have asked for, and we will show you how your coverage measures up.
What happens when the coverage doesn’t fit
Having insurance doesn’t settle what it covers. The public court record below involves other firms, not Cilantro clients, and each outcome depended on its own facts, policy language, and governing law.
Goggin v. National Union Fire Insurance
Two directors of U.S. Coal also managed separate investment entities. When claims were made about what they did in those overlapping roles, they asked for coverage under a D&O policy.
In November 2018, the Delaware Superior Court ruled that an exclusion for acts in an outside capacity applied to the claims tied to the investment entities. The ruling was about that one policy. It was not a finding of misconduct, and it did not say the directors had no insurance anywhere.
What we check for you: Every role your people hold, including board seats and other vehicles, and which policy covers each one.
Delaware Superior Court opinion, November 30, 2018